Holy Horror

I’ve met a few women whose main ambition in life was to marry a man of the cloth. I was not one of them. My goal was to meet a music major in college, which I did, but right before his graduation and our wedding he decided to become a minister. Nooooo!

If that wasn’t bad enough, I was a Lutheran – he was a Methodist. A Methodist!!!! My first and only experience with “them” had been traumatic!

I had been invited by a high school friend to her Methodist church youth group Halloween party where we played the usual embarrassing party relay games: bobbing for apples; sit on a balloon until it pops; eat a saltine cracker then try to whistle Yankee Doodle.

The party was fun, but I started getting squeamish when we were led downstairs for a mysterious adventure. Although I was concerned, I followed willingly as we wound our way through the basement halls. After all I reasoned, what could happen in a mainline denominational church? Lutherans and Methodist were the same, weren’t they?

We were finally led into a classroom and instructed to sit in a circle on the floor while an adult explained that we were being transported to the scene of a terrible car accident. Then the lights went out. Uh-oh. Lutherans would never put a bunch of teens in a dark room.

“This is a brain,” a voice called through the darkness as my hand was jammed into what felt like a bowl of warm, cooked spaghetti. Logic told me this stuff was from the kitchen of a prominent church member, but the nervous feeling in my stomach urged me to run. I would have too, if I’d thought I could find my way back out of the church basement.

Body parts continued around the circle, but I had become oblivious to them as my head began to swim. Then two round, semi-soft, warm, slimy objects were forced into the palm of my hand. “Eyeballs” I heard someone whisper. As their liquid oozed through my fingers, the Yankee Doodle saltine cracker began creeping up my throat.  I bolted for the door.

In my haste to leave the “scene of the accident”, I left the door to the classroom open, allowing the light from the hall to spill into the blackened room revealing not only the peeled grapes I had dropped on the floor, but the true identity of all the other “body parts” as well.

Repercussions from my close encounter with the Methodists were slowly overcome as I settled into my new role of minister’s wife.  The only quirky result of that horrifying holy Halloween party is that I crave the taste of a lone grape, secretly confiscated, then peeled and eaten as I walk through the fresh food section of my grocery store.

© Gayellen Kick 2016

Click subscribe at the top of the page to be notified by email when there is a new post.

Click Home to read more Stories From The Middle.

Share this post and leave a comment using the links and reply section below.

Thanks for reading! You may now continue with the unused portion of your day.


    Elisa O'NeillOctober 22nd, 2016
  1. Heh heh

  2. Harvey MackNovember 20th, 2017
  3. Very good. As a failed preachers wife, I understand

  4. Gayellen KickNovember 20th, 2017
  5. If I had a smiley emoji, Harvey, I would send you one.

Leave a Reply

Name and e-mail are required. Your e-mail will not be published.

« | »